LibreOffice has publicly criticized Euro-Office, alleging that it acts as a 'de facto ally' of Microsoft by defaulting to the proprietary OOXML document format. This move, according to LibreOffice, undermines efforts towards European digital sovereignty and reinforces vendor lock-in.
Sovereignty Concerns
The Document Foundation, the organization behind LibreOffice, has expressed concerns over Euro-Office's alignment with Microsoft's ecosystem. In an open letter, Italo Vignoli, a founding member, criticized Euro-Office for mimicking Microsoft's interface and workflows, which he argues creates a dependency on Microsoft's products. This dependency is seen as counterproductive to the sovereignty efforts that Euro-Office claims to support.
Security and Development Origins
Euro-Office's development origins have also come under scrutiny. The project is based on OnlyOffice, with up to 99% of its codebase traced back to developers in Russian time zones. This raises security concerns about potential vulnerabilities and the risk of malicious code insertion, which could undermine the project's sovereignty claims.
European Tech Firms Involvement
Despite these concerns, several European tech firms, including IONOS, Nextcloud, Eurostack, XWiki, OpenProject, Soverin, Abilian, and BTactic, are involved in the Euro-Office initiative. These companies aim to provide a sovereign alternative to Microsoft Office with a familiar interface to ease migration.
Implications for Enterprise Software Buyers
For enterprise software buyers and technology procurement leaders, the debate between LibreOffice and Euro-Office highlights the importance of evaluating software choices not just on functionality but also on the implications for vendor lock-in and digital sovereignty. The potential security risks associated with Euro-Office's development origins further complicate the decision-making process.
| Aspect | LibreOffice | Euro-Office |
|---|---|---|
| Default Format | Open Document Format (ODF) | OOXML |
| Development Origin | European | Russian |
| Sovereignty Claims | Strong | Questioned |
The ongoing rivalry between LibreOffice and Euro-Office underscores the complexities of choosing office software in a landscape where digital sovereignty and security are increasingly prioritized.
Sources:
