According to a senior government official cited by the Economic Times, India has shifted its trade strategy, favouring preferential trade agreements (PTAs) over free trade agreements (FTAs) with South Africa, Mercosur and other developing economies. The official said South Africa is not a highly developed economy, and a full FTA would require a much deeper opening up of the Indian market, a move that may not necessarily serve India's interests. The report signals a recalibration of India's approach to trade negotiations with developing economies, moving from comprehensive pacts toward targeted agreements.
PTA route for South Africa
The Economic Times reported that India has instead decided to pursue a PTA route with South Africa, under which both sides will identify specific products of mutual strength and interest. South Africa will get market access in areas where it has strengths, while India will secure access in products of its own interest. A PTA, the article explained, is a trade pact between countries that reduces tariffs and other trade barriers on selected goods traded among member nations; it does not remove all tariffs and usually applies only to a selected list of products.
| Feature | PTA as described in the report | FTA as characterised by the official |
|---|---|---|
| Market opening | Reduces tariffs and barriers on selected goods | Would require much deeper opening of the Indian market |
| Tariff coverage | Does not remove all tariffs | Not specified in the report |
| Product coverage | Applies only to a selected list of products | Not specified in the report |
Expanding PTA pipeline: Mercosur, Mexico, Kenya
The government is also moving ahead with PTA negotiations with Mercosur, the South American trade bloc comprising Brazil and other member nations, according to the Economic Times. Discussions are being explored for a possible PTA with Mexico and Kenya. Ecuador, the report said, has independently approached India expressing interest in a full FTA. The countries now in India's trade-agreement pipeline are:
- South Africa — PTA route selected over FTA
- Mercosur (including Brazil) — PTA negotiations moving ahead
- Mexico — possible PTA under discussion
- Kenya — possible PTA under discussion
- Ecuador — independently approached India for a full FTA
"Whole of government, whole of stakeholders" negotiation model
In contrast to earlier trade negotiation practices, the official said the current government ensures that all concerned stakeholders are consulted and taken on board before any trade agreement is finalised, describing the approach as a "whole of the government, whole of stakeholders" model of negotiation. The Economic Times said the official pointed to two recent stakeholder meetings — one on expanding India's shipbuilding and shipbreaking capacity and another on addressing urea diversion — both of which brought together relevant ministries, industry bodies, and private sector players to arrive at coordinated action plans, reflecting a more inclusive and consultative style of policymaking compared to earlier trade negotiation practices.
India-SACU timeline
Related reporting carried in the Economic Times article noted that India-SACU trade pact talks are to begin by September and conclude within a year, and that India and the South Africa-led SACU group may ink terms of reference for negotiating the trade pact on August 12.
The report did not specify which products are under consideration for the India-South Africa PTA, nor did it provide tariff lines or implementation dates. The official's "whole of government, whole of stakeholders" approach suggests that industry consultations will precede any finalised agreement, according to the report. For importers and exporters, the distinction matters: a PTA with South Africa will cover only selected products where each side holds strengths, rather than a comprehensive opening of the Indian market.
Sources:
